Napa County  
1195 THIRD STREET  
SUITE 310  
NAPA, CA 94559  
Agenda  
Wednesday, May 3, 2023  
9:00 AM  
Board of Supervisors Chambers  
1195 Third Street, Third Floor  
Napa, CA 94559  
Planning Commission  
Kara Brunzell, District 1  
Dave Whitmer, District 2  
Heather Phillips, District 3  
Andrew Mazotti, District 4  
Megan Dameron, District 5  
Brian Bordona, Interim Director  
Michael Parker, Planning Manager  
Laura Anderson, County Counsel  
Alexandria Quackenbush, Commission Clerk  
Aime Ramos, Commission Clerk  
Jason Hall, Commission Clerk  
How to Watch or Listen to the Napa County Planning Commission Meetings  
The Napa County Planning Commission will continue to meet pursuant to the adopted calendar  
located at the following link:  
-Airport-Land-Use-Commission-Meeting-Calendar?bidId=  
The Napa County Planning Commission realizes that not all County residents have the same ways to  
stay engaged, so several alternatives are offered. Remote Zoom participation for members of the  
public is provided for convenience only. In the event that the Zoom connection malfunctions for any  
reason, the Planning Commission reserves the right to conduct the meeting without remote access.  
Please watch or listen to the Planning Commission meeting in one of the following ways:  
1.  
Attend in-person at the Board of Supervisors Chambers, 1195 Third Street, Napa, Third  
Floor.  
2.  
"Video" column).  
3.  
4.  
Watch on your TV - Napa Valley TV Channel 28.  
sure the browser is up-to-date.  
5.  
Listen on Zoom by calling 1-669-900-6833 (Meeting ID: 99141906645).  
If you are unable to attend the meeting in person and wish to submit a general public comment or  
a comment on a specific agenda item, please do the following:  
1.  
2.  
3.  
Email your comment to planningcommissionclerk@countyofnapa.org. Emails will not be  
read aloud but will still become part of the public record and shared with the Planning  
Commission.  
browser is up-to-date. When the Chair calls for the item on which you wish to speak, click  
"raise hand". Please limit your remarks to three minutes.  
Call the Zoom phone number: 1-669-900-6833. (Meeting ID: 991-4190-6645). When the  
Chair calls for the item on which you wish to speak, press *9 to raise hand. Please limit your  
remarks to three minutes.  
**Please note that phone numbers in their entirety will be visible online while speakers are  
speaking**  
For more information, please contact us via telephone at (707) 253-4417 or send an email to  
1.  
2.  
CALL TO ORDER; ROLL CALL  
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE  
3.  
4.  
CITIZEN COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS  
APPROVAL OF MINUTES  
The Clerk of the Commission request approval of Minutes for the meeting held on:  
April 19, 2023 (All Commissioners present)  
5.  
6.  
7.  
AGENDA REVIEW  
DISCLOSURES  
ADMINISTRATIVE ITEMS  
Request: Receive an overview and presentation from Kate Miller,  
Executive Director, Napa Valley Transportation Authority about the  
agency’s V-Commute Travel Demand Management Program.  
A.  
Staff Recommendation: Informational and discussion item.  
Staff Contact: Michael Parker, Planning Manager, (707) 299-1407 -  
8.  
PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS  
DUCKHORN WINE COMPANY / DUCKHORN VINEYARDS  
WINERY / USE PERMIT MAJOR MODIFICATION (P19-00097-MOD)  
A.  
CEQA Status: Consideration and possible adoption of a Mitigated  
Negative Declaration. According to the proposed Mitigated Negative  
Declaration, the proposed project would not have any potentially  
significant environmental impacts after implementation of mitigation  
measures. Mitigation measures are proposed for the following areas:  
Biological Resources and Cultural Resources. The project site is not  
included on a list of hazardous materials sites compiled pursuant to  
Government Code Section 65962.5.  
Request: Approval of a Use Permit Major Modification to an existing  
160,000 gallon per year winery to allow the following: 1) construction of a  
58,042 sq. ft. facility (‘West Winery’) on the West Property (APN  
022-100-033) containing 54,722 sq. ft. of production space and 3,320 sq.  
ft. of office and accessory uses, a 90,000 gallon fire protection water tank,  
two 158,000 gallon irrigation storage water tanks, a 24,000 gallon  
domestic water tank, landscaping, driveways, and other winery  
improvements; 2) construction of a 8,839 sq. ft. expansion to the existing  
Estate House on the East Property (APN 022-130-010) for a total floor  
space of 18,162 sq. ft.. At build out the Estate House will consist of  
17,810 sq. ft. of accessory space and 352 sq. ft. of production space; 3)  
removal of the existing combined process and sanitary wastewater system  
on the East Property and the development of separate process and sanitary  
wastewater systems on both the East and West Properties connected  
through Directional Boring under the Napa River; 4) increase onsite  
parking spaces from 68 to 96; 5) demolition of the existing Tank Shed,  
Chais 1, 2, 3 & 4 on the East Property; 6) demolition of a single family  
residence (Red House), portions of the existing gravel driveway and other  
agricultural and single-family dwelling improvements on the West  
Property and APN 022-100-034; 7) conversion and expansion of a 16,900  
sq. ft. agricultural pond on the West Property to a 20,300 sq. ft.  
bio-retention pond; 8) removal of approximately 3.55 acres of vineyard on  
the West Property; 9) removal of approximately 49 trees; 10) increase in  
maximum annual permitted wine production from 160,000 gallons to  
300,000 gallons; 11) increase the existing daily “By Appointment” Tours  
and Tastings of 82 visitors and voluntarily abandon the winery’s existing  
pre-Winery Definition Ordinance (WDO) entitlement of 50 visitors per  
week (no more than 30 on the busiest day) for “Public Tours and Tastings”  
for a total of 219 daily visitors for By Appointment Tours and Tastings  
(110 visitors per day for Tours and Tastings without food, 109 per day for  
Tours and Tastings with food); 12) modification of the existing Marketing  
Plan allowing Private Tours and Tastings events for up to 20 guests 120  
times annually, Wine with Food Pairings events for up to 25 guests 36  
times annually, Large events for up to 600 guests twice annually, and  
Auction-related events for up to 250 guests twice annually as follows: 200  
Private Tours and Tastings annually for up to 20 guests, 40 Wine with  
Food Pairings annually for up to 25 guests, 40 Medium Events annually  
for up to 60 guests, three (3) Large Events annually for up to 400 guests  
and one (1) Auction-related event for up to 250 guests; 13) addition of  
activities in conformity with AB 2004 (on-premise consumption)) on the  
Estate House porch and landscaped gardens west of the Estate House; and  
14) Temporary relocation of approved hospitality activities (Tours and  
Tastings, Marketing Events, on-premise consumption) in and around the  
Estate House to the 2,067 sq. ft. of ground floor accessory space and  
adjacent outdoor areas of the proposed West Winery during the expansion  
of the Estate House. Hospitality activities to return to the Estate House and  
East Property upon approval of final occupancy of the Estate House. An  
Exception to the Napa County Road and Street Standards is also requested  
from a Left Turn Lane Warrant for east bound traffic on Lodi Lane  
entering the East Property driveway to avoid significant environmental  
impacts by preserving unique features of the natural environment. Staff  
has found the project to comply with N.C.C. § 18.104.230.A.1 (Wineries  
located in open space areas - setbacks) as the expansion of the existing  
Estate House, which received prior approval of its location within the  
600-foot setback from Silverado Trail through Variance application  
#98123-VAR, expands no closer to the centerline of Silverado Trail than  
the nearest point of the existing structure. The project is located on four  
(4) parcels approximately 32.35 acres in size within the AP (Agricultural  
Preserve) zoning district at 1000 Lodi Lane, St. Helena, CA 94574. APN’s  
022-130-010, 022-100-033, 022-100-034 and 022-100-035.  
Staff Recommendation: Adopt the Mitigated Negative Declaration and the  
Exception to the Napa County Roads & Street Standards and Use Permit  
Major Modification, as conditioned.  
Staff Contact: Trevor Hawkes, Supervising Planner; phone number (707)  
253-4388; email address: trevor.hawkes@countyofnapa.org  
Applicant: Alex Ryan, 1000 Lodi Lane, St. Helena, CA 94574, email  
address: alex@duckhorn.com  
Representative: George H Monteverdi, Monteverdi Consulting LLC, PO  
Box 6079, Napa, CA 94581; phone number (707) 761-2516, email  
address: george@monteverdiconsulting.com  
LADERA TRAIL NORTH LLC / LADERA VINEYARDS WINERY /  
USE PERMIT MINOR MODIFICATION P21-00294 AND VIEWSHED  
P22-00109  
B.  
CEQA STATUS: Consideration and possible adoption of a Mitigated  
Negative Declaration. According to the proposed Mitigated Negative  
Declaration, the proposed project would not have any potentially  
significant environmental impacts after implementation of mitigation  
measures. Mitigation measures are proposed for Tribal Cultural  
Resources. This project is not on any lists of hazardous waste sites  
enumerated under Government Code Section 65962.5.  
REQUEST: Approval of a Minor Modification to increase weekly  
visitation, number of employees, and add two annual marketing events to  
an existing winery. The project would allow food and wine pairings with  
tastings and marketing events and permit on-premises consumption on the  
outdoor patios. Physical changes on site include expanding the tasting  
room storage building to a total of approximately 1,200 s.f., construction  
of an 8,800 s.f. cave, improvements to the existing driveway, and a  
modified parking lot. Improvements to the existing water and wastewater  
systems would be required, along with installation of a left turn lane on  
Silverado Trail in front of the project driveway. The project includes a  
determination that the proposed cave wall and portals meet the  
Administrative Criteria under the Viewshed Protection Program (Chapter  
18.106.040.C of the Napa County Code). The Viewshed component of the  
project has been administratively approved by the Director, pending  
approval of the underlying minor modification. The project site is located  
on a 7.44-acre parcel at 3942 Silverado Trail, Calistoga, CA 94515. The  
General Plan designation is Agriculture, Watershed, and Open Space  
(AWOS) the Zoning is Agricultural Watershed (AW). APN: 021-030-047  
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the Mitigated Negative  
Declaration and approve the Use Permit Major Modification and  
Viewshed application, as conditioned.  
STAFF CONTACT: Emily Hedge, Planner III, (707) 259-8226 or  
APPLICANT REPRESENTATIVE CONTACT: Chris Artley, P.O. Box  
27917 Scottsdale, AZ 85255;  
(480) 609-9225; chris@laderavineyards.com  
APPLICANT AGENT CONTACT: Thomas Adams, 1455 1st Street, Suite  
301, Napa, CA 94559; (707) 252-7122; tadams@dpf-law.com  
Attachments:  
9.  
DIRECTOR OR DIRECTOR'S DESIGNEE REPORT  
- DISCUSSION OF ITEMS FOR THE MAY 17, 2023 REGULAR MEETING  
- BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ACTIONS  
- OTHER DEPARTMENT ACTIVITIES  
- CODE COMPLIANCE REPORT  
- ZONING ADMINISTRATOR ACTIONS  
- OTHER PENDING PROJECTS' STATUS  
10.  
11.  
COMMISSIONER COMMENTS/COMMITTEE REPORTS  
PROJECTS REQUIRING COMMISSION FOLLOW-UP REVIEW  
12. ADJOURNMENT  
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE AGENDA FOR THE ABOVE STATED MEETING WAS POSTED AT A  
LOCATION FREELY ACCESSIBLE TO MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC AT THE NAPA COUNTY  
ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING, 1195 THIRD STREET, NAPA, CALIFORNIA ON (DATE) BY 2:30 P.M. A  
HARDCOPY SIGNED VERSION OF THE CERTIFICATE IS ON FILE WITH THE CLERK OF THE  
COMMISSION AND AVAILABLE FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION.  
ALEXANDRIA QUACKENBUSH(By e-signature)  
Alexandria Quackenbush, Clerk of the Commission